UNFUCG
DashboardSearchChatBookmarksNotificationsActivityPremiumProfile
?
Home
Search
Chat
Saved
Profile
Episode
Melatonin Linked to 90% Increase in Heart Failure (what to do next)
~46 min
Episode Brief·YouTube

Melatonin Linked to 90% Increase in Heart Failure (what to do next)

Thomas DeLauer
Watch on YouTube Add to chat My bookmarks← All sources

TL;DR

The four things you'd lose by not watching

4 items

TL;DR

The four things you'd lose by not watching

4 items
1

A preliminary 130,800-person study linked melatonin use in people with insomnia to a 90% increased heart failure risk, 3.5× more hospitalizations, and 1.8× higher all-cause mortality, but Thomas DeLauer argues it's likely reverse causation: those with melatonin in their medical records had more severe insomnia.

2

Melatonin is a circadian tuner and antioxidant, not a sedative; its short half-life helps sleep onset but may disrupt sleep architecture, causing wake-ups later in the night.

3

The study didn't account for unmeasured variables; people with documented melatonin use probably had worse insomnia, possibly used other sleep aids or self-medicated, making the association correlational, not causal.

4

For those wanting to improve sleep without melatonin, DeLauer recommends glycine (3 g), magnesium (400–500 mg), grounding, fresh air, L-theanine (200–400 mg), phosphatidylserine (100–300 mg), and even creatine.

Protocols

Concrete recipes — what, when, how much, and why

6 items

Glycine before bed

WhatTake 3 grams of glycine about 30 minutes to an hour before sleep.
When30–60 minutes before bedtime
Dose3 grams
For whomPeople who wake up anxious, have trouble staying asleep, or wake to pee; speaker personally benefited.
WhyIncreases natural melatonin response, lowers core body temperature, reduces cortisol and anxiety awakenings, and calms the bladder to reduce night-time urination.

DeLauer explains glycine works through multiple mechanisms: it promotes a drop in body temperature, which is a natural sleep signal; it acts as a neurotransmitter/neuromodulator that lowers cortisol and calms the nervous system, preventing those 3 a.m. anxiety spikes; and it relaxes the bladder, reducing the urge to urinate. He highlights his own problem of waking to pee and not falling back asleep, which glycine solved. He references a dedicated video on his channel about glycine for nocturia. The 3-gram dose is well tolerated and not associated with next-day grogginess. It's a practical alternative for those wanting to avoid melatonin.

Mechanism

Glycine is a co-agonist of NMDA receptors but at lower doses may enhance inhibitory signaling via glycine receptors, leading to decreased sympathetic output. It also promotes peripheral vasodilation that lowers body temperature, a key sleep trigger. By reducing stress hormones, it prevents cortisol-driven arousals.

Personal experience

DeLauer says: 'That was me. I would have to pee and then I would never fall back asleep. So, this video breaks down really well on how to use glycine and why it works in that case.'

3 g of glycine about 30 minutes to an hour before bed has an amazing effect on cooling your body. So, it increases your natural melatonin response.

Also said
“It has a neurotransmitter effect that actually lowers cortisol and keeps you calm throughout the night.”— Another mechanism beyond cooling.
“It also calms your bladder so you don't feel you have to get up to pee.”— Addresses a common sleep disruptor in older adults.

Magnesium for sleep

WhatTake 400–500 mg of magnesium before bed.
WhenBefore bed
Dose400–500 mg
For whomAnyone seeking a non-pharmacological sleep aid, especially those with racing thoughts.
WhyBinds to NMDA receptors, producing a calming GABAergic effect that shifts the brain from excitatory glutamate states to a rest-and-digest mode.
CaveatsForm of magnesium not specified; some forms may cause gastrointestinal upset.

DeLauer positions magnesium as a simple way to quiet brain activity. By blocking NMDA receptors, it reduces excitatory neurotransmission and supports GABA activity, which is central to relaxation. The 400–500 mg range aligns with common supplement recommendations. He does not go into details about different magnesium types (e.g., glycinate vs. citrate), but the implication is a well-absorbed form that crosses the blood-brain barrier. This advice fits with a broader practice of using magnesium for insomnia and anxiety.

Mechanism

NMDA receptor antagonism reduces glutamate-mediated excitation, while magnesium also potentiates GABA-A receptor function, leading to neural inhibition and parasympathetic activation.

Magnesium in the amount of 4 to 500 millig binds to what is called the NMDA receptor which has a very calming gabaurgic effect.

Also said
“Makes your brain in that more calm, relaxed, rest and digest state rather than the turned on glutamate state where you're fired up and ready to rock.”— Contrasts glutamate-driven arousal with GABA calm.

Grounding/earthing before bed

WhatStand or sit barefoot on natural surfaces like concrete, dirt, or grass for a period before bed.
WhenBefore bed
DoseNot specified; 'for a while'
For whomPeople open to unconventional practices; evidence is limited.
WhyMay lower cortisol and reduce inflammation through absorption of free electrons from the earth.
CaveatsAsphalt does not conduct; evidence is not robust due to lack of research funding.

DeLauer acknowledges the evidence is limited, not because grounding doesn't work but because there's little financial incentive to study standing on grass. He cites salivary cortisol and inflammatory marker reductions in existing small studies. It's a free, low-risk practice that may support the parasympathetic shift before sleep. He emphasizes concrete (not asphalt) as a conductor. This advice is given as a complementary tool, not a primary intervention.

Mechanism

Hypothesized that direct contact with the earth allows transfer of free electrons, neutralizing reactive oxygen species and reducing inflammation, which in turn lowers HPA axis activation.

Just getting on the concrete, not asphalt because asphalt doesn't conduct concrete, dirt, grass sounds crazy, but touching some grass for a while has an effect when it comes down to free electrons and being able to calm your body up.

Also said
“This can lower cortisol. And we've seen this in salivary cortisol tests. We've seen it in inflammatory markers.”— Mentions specific measurable outcomes.

Crack a window for fresh air

WhatOpen a window to allow circulation of fresh air and reduce bedroom CO2 levels.
WhenBefore and during sleep
DoseOngoing
For whomEveryone, especially those with poor bedroom ventilation.
WhyHigh CO2 in the bedroom disrupts sleep; fresh air lowers CO2 and improves sleep quality.

DeLauer points to studies showing elevated CO2 in closed bedrooms impairs sleep. Simply cracking a window can reduce CO2 build-up, which is a passive, cost-free intervention. It's a small behavioral change that doesn't require supplements.

Mechanism

High ambient CO2 can increase respiratory rate and cause subtle acidosis, leading to arousals. Lowering CO2 helps maintain stable sleep architecture.

We have studies that show that higher levels of CO2 that build in the uh bedroom will cause you to sleep less, right? So, get some fresh air circulating.

L-Theanine for sleep

WhatTake 200–400 mg of L-theanine before bed.
WhenBefore bed
Dose200–400 mg
For whomThose with stress-related sleep trouble.
WhyCrosses the blood-brain barrier and calms the brain, promoting relaxation.

This recommendation is brief. L-theanine is an amino acid found in green tea that increases alpha brain waves and GABA levels. The 200–400 mg dose is typical for sleep and anxiety support. DeLauer presents it as a quick stop-gap for stress without side effects.

Mechanism

L-theanine enhances inhibitory neurotransmitters (GABA) and modulates alpha brain wave activity, reducing neuronal excitability.

2 to 400 milligrams of theine. Theine crosses the bloodb brain barrier, calms the body, calms the brain.

Phosphatidylserine for cortisol blunting

WhatTake 100–300 mg of phosphatidylserine on a stressful day, ideally before bed.
WhenWhen stressed, before bed
Dose100–300 mg
For whomPeople with high stress days that might throw off normal diurnal cortisol patterns.
WhyTemporarily blunts cortisol and supports cell membrane health, preventing cortisol-driven disruption of sleep rhythms.

DeLauer emphasizes that phosphatidylserine is not just a calming agent; it helps keep cortisol rhythms from becoming chaotic. He notes its role in protecting the phospholipid bilayer, providing antioxidant support from daily oxidative stress. The dose of 100–300 mg is specific, and it's positioned as a strategic use for particularly stressful days, not a nightly staple.

Mechanism

Phosphatidylserine blunts the ACTH-driven cortisol release by modulating the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, likely through cell membrane stabilization and receptor function.

1 to 300 milligs of phospatidyl serereine and it helps calm your body and blunts the cortisol which could be throwing off your entire dal rhythms.

Also said
“There's also a lot of evidence showing that it is a temporary break on cortisol.”— Highlights the temporary, targeted nature of the effect.

What's new

Personal practice updates, fresh positions, predictions

3 items

New study links melatonin to 90% increased heart failure risk

early in video

A not-yet-peer-reviewed study of 130,800 adults with insomnia found that those taking melatonin (documented in medical records for >12 months) had a 90% higher heart failure incidence, 3.5× more hospitalizations, and 1.8× increased all-cause mortality compared to insomnia patients without melatonin in their charts.

Why this matters: Challenges the widespread belief that melatonin is a benign sleep supplement; the numbers are stark and widely covered in media but need careful interpretation.

Background

Melatonin is widely used over the counter and considered safe, with many people taking it for chronic insomnia. Prior research had not shown such cardiovascular risks.

The study was presented at the American Heart Association Scientific Sessions in early November 2025 and is preliminary, lacking peer review. DeLauer emphasizes that the comparison was between two groups of insomniacs, which is better than comparing to healthy controls, but the critical flaw is that the 'melatonin group' was defined by having melatonin noted in their electronic health record. This likely selects for people with more severe, treatment-resistant insomnia—those who have complained enough to have it recorded and may have been prescribed clinical doses or adjunct sleep aids. The control group of insomniacs without melatonin in their chart could still be taking it over the counter without disclosure, further muddying the comparison. DeLauer calls this reverse causation: the severity of insomnia drives both the need for documented melatonin and the higher cardiovascular risk, not the melatonin itself. The study authors themselves note the correlation is unadjusted for such confounders and lacks mechanistic evidence.

It found that there was a 90% increased risk of heart failure in those that took the melatonin compared to those that didn't. A 4.6% incidence of heart failure compared to a 2.7% risk of heart failure.

Also said
“3.5x increase hospitalization in the group that took melatonin compared to the group that did not and a 1.8x increase in all cause mortality.”— Additional risk metrics beyond heart failure, reinforcing the shocking headline figures.
“This is a perfect classic example of reverse causation.”— His central critique of the study's interpretation.

Melatonin likely not causing heart failure; study buried by reverse causation

mid video after study description

DeLauer argues the association is almost certainly due to worse baseline health in the melatonin-documented group, not a direct cardiotoxic effect of melatonin.

Why this matters: Offers a detailed rebuttal that mainstream headlines miss, highlighting the unmeasured variables and the low barrier for OTC melatonin use making the control group unreliable.

Background

Many news outlets reported the study as proof that melatonin causes heart failure.

He explains the unmeasured variables problem: people whose insomnia is severe enough to prompt a doctor to note melatonin in their chart are also more likely to have higher cortisol, sympathetic tone, inflammation, and to be self-medicating with alcohol or other drugs. The more severe the insomnia, the higher the cardiovascular risk, independent of melatonin. Moreover, because melatonin is over-the-counter, controls may be using it without reporting, biasing the result toward null or even underestimating the harm if it were real, but the crucial point is that the groups are not matched on insomnia severity. The study's matching only on 'having insomnia' is too crude. DeLauer also notes Dr. Domino, a neuroscychopharmacologist, argued on his channel that melatonin's antioxidant properties are beneficial, further casting doubt on a direct causal link.

They did not account for unmeasured variables. … people that have been taking melatonin for a year or more, and it's in their chart, are probably dealing with significantly more severe insomnia than people that don't have melatonin in their chart.

Also said
“Melatonin is just the canary in the coal mine.”— Pithy summary of his reverse-causation thesis.
“The biggest thing here, and this is a huge, huge, huge thing, they did not account for unmeasured variables.”— Emphasis on the study's fatal flaw.

Expert's personal skepticism toward melatonin due to sleep architecture disruption, not heart failure risk

mid video

DeLauer admits he is not a melatonin fan because its short half-life helps sleep onset but often leads to waking up later, degrading sleep quality; he does not believe it causes heart failure.

Why this matters: Provides a nuanced personal stance: the real problem is poor sleep quality from melatonin rebound, not the alarming study.

Background

Common belief is that melatonin just helps you sleep; many users don't realize it can fragment sleep.

He distinguishes between melatonin's role as a circadian tuner—signaling the body it's nighttime—and a sedative. Because its half-life is only 40–60 minutes, people may fall asleep quickly but then experience a cortisol spike or an arousal later, leading to middle-of-the-night waking. He believes some people respond well, others do not, and that his concern is about sleep architecture rather than any direct cardiovascular toxicity. This skepticism is separate from the study; he would not recommend melatonin based on its uneven effects.

I'm not the biggest melatonin fan. The reason I'm not the biggest melatonin fan is like I mentioned earlier, it helps people fall asleep, but a lot of times they'll wake up a few hours later and it can disrupt their sleep architecture.

Also said
“The halfife of melatonin is only like 40 minutes to an hour. It doesn't last long.”— Supports the mechanism of sleep fragmentation.
Disclosed sponsorships1speaker disclosed

Create Creatine Gummies

Supplement Sponsored · disclosed

DeLauer claims creatine can improve sleep by supporting energy reserves, aiding recovery, and reducing inflammation, which promotes deeper sleep. He recommends Create's creatine gummies sweetened with allulose to offset carbohydrates.

DisclosureLink in video description provides up to 54% off; speaker states it's his personal favorite and one he uses.

The video is not primarily about creatine, but DeLauer transitions from the sleep discussion to promote his sponsored/affiliated product. He argues that creatine's sleep benefit is indirect: by enhancing mitochondrial function and muscle recovery, it lowers systemic inflammation, which in turn allows deeper sleep. The gummies are presented as a convenient, palatable form, and the discount is a strong call to action. The scientific linkage to sleep, while plausible, is given minimal mechanistic depth.

Personal experience

I put a link down below for my favorite creatine. … the one that I personally use.

Creatine can help you sleep. And it does so because it helps with these energy reserves that actually allow your body to recover a little bit better and consequently can reduce the inflammation that allows you to get into a deeper state of sleep.

Also said
“That link down below gets you up to 54% off their creatine gummies that are sweetened with alulose. So, it cancels out some of the carbohydrates.”— Details the specific product and its unique sweetener.
Find Create

Notable quotes

Lines worth pulling out — contrarian, specific, or perfectly phrased

4 items
Melatonin is just the canary in the coal mine.
Concise metaphor for how the study reflects severe insomnia, not melatonin's toxicity.
This is a perfect classic example of reverse causation.
Declares the study's core statistical flaw in clear terms.
I'm not the biggest melatonin fan. … it helps people fall asleep, but a lot of times they'll wake up a few hours later and it can disrupt their sleep architecture.
Personal stance that goes beyond the study, based on sleep quality.
They did not account for unmeasured variables. … people that have been taking melatonin for a year or more, and it's in their chart, are probably dealing with significantly more severe insomnia.
The central criticism of the study's design, directly undercutting the headlines.

Sign in to share feedback

Tell us if this brief hit the mark or missed it — feedback feeds back into the next iteration of the prompt.

Topics covered

melatonin-heart-failure-studyreverse-causationmelatonin-circadian-tunermelatonin-sleep-architectureglycine-sleepmagnesium-sleepgrounding-earthingfresh-air-sleepl-theanine-sleepphosphatidylserine-cortisolcreatine-sleep
Free account

Make this library yours

Reading is free for everyone. A free account adds the personal layer: save protocols, follow experts, and see how the other experts weigh in on this same topic.

Create a free accountSign in

Where the experts disagree — weekly

One email a week: the sharpest new disagreements and protocols from the library. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Educational summary of the cited expert source — not medical advice. Open the source recording linked above and consult a qualified physician before acting on any protocol.